Man, this is the same as people who drive 5 mph under the limit everywhere and call it safe driving, it's just fear dressed up as wisdom.

Blackstone and Shaw is where mine got hit two years back, same deal where the pump accepted the card and my phone buzzed about a Best Buy order in Vegas an hour later. Those skimmers sit over the real card slot so the pump reads the strip on the fake one and passes it through, which is why nothing looks broken and the machine acts normal. Now I grab the reader housing and wiggle it every single time, if it lifts up even a little I skip that pump and go inside. I also pay inside with cash or tap to pay, since the tap reader is way harder to fake than the swipe slot. Check the seal stickers on the panel too, if the tape is cut or the sticker is peeled they've been in there. Fresno has had a bunch of these along Blackstone and Shaw, so it's not just bad luck.